The TaraSpan Blog
Apr 30

City smart. Village smarter.

Posted on April 30th, by Parminder Singh 2 Comments

smart city

Every time the adjective smart is added to a person, concept, idea, or a device, it has elicited general interest. However, more often than not, smart turned out to be rather dumb.  Take the “smart” phone for instance, I have given up trying to tell it that “I really am wanting to type “of” and would you please let me do it? “ It has a mind of its own and will always try and change the “of” to an “if”!

Smart Cities are likely to face the same predicament.

To begin with, what makes a city smart? The underlying philosophy is that a lot of stuff would happen on its own. All that you need to provide is a power connection and a broadband pipe and lo and behold! You have smartness.

The reality is rather far removed. The first and foremost requirement of a smart city is the unification of thought amongst the various agencies: electricity distribution, sewage disposal, water supplies, road maintenance, law enforcement, traffic management, and the hundreds of government agencies that contribute in running a city.

Once this unification happens, then activities amongst these agencies would expectedly get coordinated and no one would work in isolation. From an Indian standpoint, there is little to show that such coordination is possible. The electronics and technology are the better manageable parts of the solution. Getting teams to work together is the complex part.

“Villages, being small units, do not have complex departments and bureaucracy. Secondly, the degree of smartness required would also be low to begin with.”

Which brings me to my core point. Why not make villages smart? Villages being small units, do not have complex departments and bureaucracy. Secondly, the degree of smartness required would also be low to begin with. One can start with electricity distribution, street lighting, public distribution, banking, post office, government services, health care, education (child and adult), farmers’ assistance, procurement, edutainment and infotainment. The list of things that can be automated and delivered to the village dweller at the village doorstep is long and of significant value to the average village dweller.

Why make villages smart and how with automated technology?

Improved productivity

A direct dividend of making a village smarter is saving man-days and improving the average productivity of an individual. With this, an incentive is also available for people to not migrate to the cities. The domino effect of this process is an increasing entrepreneurship in the villages. 

Lower cost

The cost of smartening up a village will be considerably lower as compared to cities. The key factor weighing in favor of villages is that laying a broadband infrastructure will be simpler. In most village environments a prudent mix of fiber, Wi-Fi, TV white spaces would be sufficient to build a robust network that can be back hauled via fiber to the village (FTTV?). Right of way approvals that are a bane to any project in cities would be non-existent in villages.

The other key ingredient is power supply. Here, most Indian villages get abundance of sunshine. Hence using solar power along with biomass based power can complement the power supply from the state electricity board.


Maintaining the system and its upkeep can be entrusted to the villagers as a business proposal, just like one would outsource the maintenance of a system in a city to an SI. This would create a demand for technical skill sets and generate employment for the local youth.  

Hence making villages smart would help close the digital divide, reduce rural to urban migrations, improve productivity (and GDP), create jobs, improve the work life balance of the people.

That, I would say, would be a smart move.



Parminder Singh
Written by Parminder Singh
Parminder is the Vice President of Sales with TaraSpan Solutions and writes on various aspects of technology.


What is Softphone? Learn about its Features, Benefits & Much More
Apr 01st, 2020

Professional communication has become the pressing priority for organizations to survive in this cut-throat era. Plus, it should be consistent, reliable, secure, agile, and uninterrupted to flow with the ...

How SD-WAN Improves Unified Communications
Mar 25th, 2019

Round the Clock- Unified Communication is helping businesses in many ways. Ranging from a voice call to video to live chat to screen sharing to webinars, UC is proving ...

    Sunil Malagi May 1, 2015 at 7:50 am

    I agree on most of the thoughts in defining “smart”. But would not entirely agree on starting with villages. That would amount to treating the heels when the pain is in the head. Villages, first need to develop basic infra structure and their priorities are more different.

    shakar May 1, 2015 at 1:03 pm

    Indeed a thought provoking article. Why not take it forward?
    Why not pick up a village / tehsil of say 25,000 people and draw up a roadmap. I am willing to join and do my bit on solar power side…..


Leave Your Comment